Monday, June 20, 2011

Ingenuity or Hannah is Creative

When I took this picture Hannah asked me, with a roll of the eyes, if I was going to put it on the blog. I told her that I would, only if it were OK with her. She smiled, raised her eyebrows and said, "Only if you call it Hannah is Creative." I agreed. My agreement wasn't wrangled out of me: she is creative. For example, she would absolutely love an iPod; however, her parents don't feel the same way; so, she made her own out of beads and wire. And now she has moved on to video games. I found her seated in front of her dresser a little before bedtime with her homemade video game. I thought that it was brilliant.
p.s. Doesn't her side-profile look a wee bit like mine?

Now, as a sort of sidebar: our banning of iPods, video games and the like from our children isn't because we are Luddites or believe that technology is evil. I am blogging, am I not? And, Dave has an iPod that he uses quite frequently, especially when he exercises. Plus, I think that Dave is one of the best and most effective users of technology in the classroom. We are plugged in; but, we still choose to keep our own children fairly unplugged.

Childhood is fleeting. Our main beef with video games, iPods and excessive television is that, aside from being socially isolating and somewhat mindless, they tend to waste a childhood.

We both grew up under parents who were very judicious about their use of technology with us. Of course, at that point technology was mostly limited to the TV. I grew up encouraged by academic parents who read books and taught us to do the same. Lively discussions at the dinner table about great ideas, faith and the moral life are good memories of mine. Dave was raised on a farm and fairly ate, slept and drank hard work and exercise. He recalls watching a show called SkiBoy which inspired him to ski around and around and around his house until he was exhausted. Together, our parenting philosophy has become read books, go to mass, pray with children, talk about and live faith, and wear them out physically so that they have no time to get in trouble and so that they sleep. Sleep is very important. Pretty simple, actually. We'll see if it works.

But, back to the wasting of childhood. I want to see my kids running outdoors, playing in sandboxes, wading in pools, jumping off of picnic tables (yes, they do) and bonding with one another in the great cathedral of the outdoors. I don't want to plunk them down in front of screens to simply keep them busy and out of my hair.
Nevertheless, technology certainly comes in handy around here: I like to teach Ben to read using books; however, starfall.com has definitely filled in some holes and taught him how to use a computer mouse. The kids love movies and I made my way through Jacob's years of eye-patching using the TV.

So, are we out of step with the times? Yes, I have no problem admitting that. We are, I suppose, old-fashioned. But, I kind of like the way old-fashioned kids grow up into really interesting, morally-grounded adults. At least I think they do. Plus, if Hannah can build a video game out of lego and her brothers' trucks, then I can only imagine what she might do with some better materials.
She eventually allowed her brother a chance to play.
And then there's him. He is currently training for some sort of special-ops team. Jumping off of picnic tables is suitable preparation.

6 comments:

Julie Culshaw said...

Remember the year dad said you could watch tv at 9 pm, and it just coincided with the CBC's trial of putting on the National at 9 pm. Of course, you had to be in bed by 10, so that ended any shows for you. It was hilarious at the time, and still brings a smile now.

Jenna Craine said...

Elena, I think it's great to limit your kids' use of technology. Of the families I have spent time with, the kids who play the least amount of video games and watch the leas amount of tv are best at having real conversations with adults. And also seem less SUSPICIOUS or BORED by adults. (So then you can get in the great dinner table conversations like you had as a child.) Plus, saying no to Hannah's iPod request is healthy by the very fact that it's good to for kids to hear the word 'no.' When I was helping out with Lifeteen it was a source of great frustration how many of the kids showed up with the telltale white earbuds in their ears. I am pretty certain that half of the music they were playing was fairly offensive too.

Elena said...

Jenna, I completely agree with your comment about suspicion and boredom. I strongly feel that the unnatural division of family and kids often caused by school is only exacerbated by texting, video games, tv etc. I think that we have a belief that teens are just naturally bad and I don't believe that that is true. I also find the white earbuds difficult - sort of like a big sign that says I am not interested in you. Social isolation.

Jaclyn said...

I have to agree about the interaction-with-adults point, as I have already noticed this with Norah and her peers. At 3.5-4 years old, three of Norah's friends from church have little-to-no ability to interact with adults. Now this *may* be just an age thing, but it's worth noting that all three of them *routinely* watch feature-length films. (As in, at least once a day.)

Now I agree that technology has its benefits - a Handy Manny online game gets credit for the fact that Norah can handle addition - but I think strong limits prevent it from taking over one's life. And on that note, I think I'll shut the computer down now.

Robinsonpack said...

I know this is an old post, but the conversation interested me, and so I have bene thinking about it over the last few days.

At different times our family has had different levels of technology use. In our early years of marriage Jordan and I never had cable, video games, rarely watched movies etc. At other times (for example when I was very sick with pregnancies) I am sad to say the tv was on the majority of the time. We now let each child have one short show (20 to 30 minutes each- Sarah doesn't get a show at age 1!) Some people may judge us that this is a ton, while others might feel this is nothing. For us, this is what works. It allows me to have a moment of my choosing in the day to get something done without said child at my feet.

Isaiah also gets some video game time in the day, usually on my ipad and a majority of it needs to be montasory educational games however he does get a few minutes of sonic or some other mindless game. Again, I know that some may judge, however, this allows quiet time (when the other two are napping- he can't read yet and looking at picture books only holds his attention for a short time) to be quiet for me and I get to have a mommy nap which saves my sanity.

I remember being new parents and going to a park once to overhear a mom say to a child, "now you get to go home and have shows, how does that sound?" Jordan and I looked at each other and we both knew we were totally judging this poor lady... "what a bad mom, letting the tv babysit her child." Now I am totally ashamed that I sat in such judgment of her.

I think it is good to have ideals regarding technology. At the same time, I think we do what we can, and I know for myself my tendency is to judge myself much more harshly than I judge others. When I read posts, and comments like this I have the other bad habit of comparing myself. I think, wow, she is super mom... or if that commentor thinks that woman is bad for she would for sure think I am the worst mom ever.

At the same time, I do like hearing other people's thoughts, and I always love reading your blog Elena as it allows me to re-evaluate what we do in our home and to get different ideas from someone I respect.

Anyway, that is my own two cents, sorry for the super long post and it took me forever to comment, I have been mulling this over.

Elena said...

Theresa, I hope you check back for my response because the TV is on here and the kids are watching Peter Pan. I have always used TV and have gone through real phases of beating myself up about it being on. We by no means have a ban on TV. We did get rid of satellite but that was because Dave and I had a problem with too much TV and we could see how it would trickle down far too easily. We do have a ban on video games but the kids play games on the computer like starfall, thomas and handy manny. The ban on video games is so that our kids don't sit for hours doing the easy thing or the default activity that video games often becomes. It scares me when I see kids, mostly boys, who exist within a cyber world and are unable to engage an adult and sometimes their own peers in a conversation. Also, so many parents have no idea what games their kids are actually playing and the levels of violence and sexuality are very high.
We don't ban electronics - we just try to stay a step ahead and to limit them as much as is possible. Around these parts that means that while the babies nap the older kids usually watch TV. I used to feel horrible about that but then I realised that once the kids are in school they watch very little TV - a movie or show on the weekend. It all levels out eventually and we are very flexible but constantly reassessing our use of TV and computers. The end.
p.s. don't feel badly - sounds like your kids watch less tv than mine!